http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/remove-markley-dennis
Remove Markley Dennis
Terry, Debbi, Chris, Heather & Morgan ElvisMyrtle Beach, South Carolina
We the family of Heather R. Elvis, the people of Horry County, The State of South Carolina and beyond our borders do seek to allow justice to be served in an unprejudicial manner. In order to accomplish this task, we seek to have Judge Rupert Markley Dennis Jr. recuse himself and allow the South Carolina Supreme Court to appoint a judge who will correct the following issues and see that justice is done fairly and that the appearance of any impropriety is removed from the courts in this case.
First, ever since judge Markley has been over this case ( it was originally under the rule of then honorable Administrative Judge Johns ) we the family have been made to travel to Charleston South Carolina for each hearing and motion which forces us to close our business, uproot our lives and family and travel around 3 hours round trip not to mention the time spent in court. It is a hardship that is supposed to be avoided for the families of violent crime yet is not even given a second thought with each hearing. Not only does our family have to make the trip and lose business and time but those friends and supporters are forced to make the trip. This is and has been a hardship on all of those who make the trip not to mention the tax payer funded travel expenses for the solicitors office and all of the staff needed to handle the court motions. If this judge does not want to travel to Horry County then please allow a local judge to preside over this case.
Secondly, we have been denied the constitutional right to speak at the last bond modification hearing. This right is given to us under the Constitution of South Carolina.
Article 1 Section 24 (A)(4) of the South Carolina Constitution "Victim's Bill of Rights" - that one says a victim has the right to "be reasonably informed of and be allowed to submit either a written or oral statement at all hearings affecting bond or bail"
ARTICLE I
SECTION 24 Passed January 22, 1998 at 1:50 PM
SECTION 24 Passed January 22, 1998 at 1:50 PM
Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of South Carolina:
"Section 24. (A) To preserve and protect victims' rights to justice and due process regardless of race, sex, age, religion, or economic status, victims of crime have the right to:
(1) be treated with fairness, respect, and dignity, and to be free from intimidation, harassment, or abuse, throughout the criminal and juvenile justice process, and informed of the victim's constitutional rights, provided by statute;
(2) be reasonably informed when the accused or convicted person is arrested, released from custody, or has escaped;
(3) be informed of and present at any criminal proceedings which are dispositive of the charges where the defendant has the right to be present;
(4) be reasonably informed of and be allowed to submit either a written or oral statement at all hearings affecting bond or bail;
(5) be heard at any proceeding involving a post-arrest release decision, a plea, or sentencing;
(6) be reasonably protected from the accused or persons acting on his behalf throughout the criminal justice process;
(7) confer with the prosecution, after the crime against the victim has been charged, before the trial or before any disposition and informed of the disposition;
(8) have reasonable access after the conclusion of the criminal investigation to all documents relating to the crime against the victim before trial;
(9) receive prompt and full restitution from the person or persons convicted of the criminal conduct that caused the victim's loss or injury including both adult and juvenile offenders;
(10) be informed of any proceeding when any post-conviction action is being considered, and be present at any post-conviction hearing involving a post-conviction release decision;
(11) a reasonable disposition and prompt and final conclusion of the case;
(12) have all rules governing criminal procedure and the admissibility of evidence in all criminal proceedings protect victims' rights and have these rules subject to amendment or repeal by the legislature to ensure protection of these rights.
To Be Clear.
`Victim' means a person who suffers direct or threatened physical, psychological, or financial harm as the result of the commission or attempted commission of a crime against him. The term `victim' also includes the person's spouse, parent, child, or lawful representative of a crime victim who is deceased, who is a minor or who is incompetent or who was a homicide victim or who is physically or psychologically incapacitated.
Thirdly, a disturbing fact has been brought to our attention this week by the Horry County Solicitors office that causes our family to have a large amount to distrust in the ability of Judge Markley Dennis to be fair and impartial on this case. It has been revealed that Judge Markley Dennis was a schoolmate of the defendant's father ( Sidney Moorer ). They went to the same school in a much smaller town of Summerville South Carolina area. This causes us great concern as to a potential conflict in any proceedings in our daughter Heather's case, when heard before Judge Markley Dennis. Keep in mind that before Judge Dennis was assigned this case, the defendants were incarcerated without bail even though they tried to get bail before Judge Johns and failed.
According to the Sworn Statement to the Judicial Merit Selection Commission, Circuit Court Judge Rupert Markley Dennis Jr. then an incumbent judge stated the following to the commission.
QUOTED from paragraph (6)
"My philosophy on recusal is consistent with and specifically set forth in Canon 3(E). In those situations, I disclose the potential problems and ask the parties to consider out of my presence whether they wish me to recuse myself. If requested, recusal is always the correct approach. There are occasions,, however, where I may decline to recuse myself when it appears the party is simply trying to gain an advantage or possible further delay which would constitute a prejudice to the other side. In those situations nothing in the Canons would prevent me from hearing the matter."
Paragraph (7) QUESTION ASKED:
If you disclosed something that had the appearance of bias, but you believed it would not actually prejudice your impartiality, what deference would you give a party that requested your recusal?
ANSWER GIVEN:
As stated, I would in those situations, elect to recuse myself to avoid the appearance of impropriety.
{These answers were given and sworn to by Judge Rupert Markley Dennis Jr. on the 4th day of August 2014 and the Notary who signed the papers was Linda J. Droze}
To Summarize our concerns:
(A) The undoing of the first Judges ( Honorable Judge John ) denial of bond.
(B) Letting the accused travel out of state.
(C) Setting an order that they could work in boardering states to South Carolina.
(D) Allowed them to move to and seek employment in FLORIDA ( last time I looked we don't share a boarder with FLORIDA).
(E) Allowing the accused to break the gag order without punishment.
(F) Being denied our constitutional right to speak at the bond reconsideration hearing when it was clearly stated at the beginning of the hearing, is a violation of our rights.
(G) Not disclosing the fact that he Judge Markley Dennis knew, and attended school with the father of Sidney Moorer ( one of the defendants ) and grew up in the same small town area. This should have been addressed earlier on so as to decide if it was a problem BEFORE any rulings were made.
All of this taken as a whole is overwhelmingly prejudicial in our eyes and we hereby request that Judge Markey Dennis abide by his sworn statement to the Judicial Merit Commission and recuse himself from the case of our loving daughter Heather R. Elvis immediately.
Respectfully Submitted.
The Elvis Family, Friends and Concerned Citizens of South Carolina and those beyond its borders.
*** I would ask that anyone who feels that this injustice should be investigated, please write a complaint to the South Carolina State Supreme Court addressed to the the Honorable Chief Justice Costa M. Pleicones and the Commission on Judicial Conduct / Disciplinary Council at the following addresses.
Mailing Address:
Office of Disciplinary Counsel
Lesley M. Coggiola
Disciplinary Counsel
Disciplinary Counsel
Barbara M. Seymour
Deputy Disciplinary Counsel
Deputy Disciplinary Counsel
Office Location:
1220 Senate Street
Suite 309
Columbia, South Carolina 29201
Telephone: (803) 734-2038
Fax: (803) 734-1964
1220 Senate Street
Suite 309
Columbia, South Carolina 29201
Telephone: (803) 734-2038
Fax: (803) 734-1964
How to File a Complaint
There are no forms or other special requirements to file a complaint, but some things are necessary for both judicial and lawyer complaints. Any complaint filed with either the Commission on Judicial Conduct or the Commission on Lawyer Conduct needs to be in writing and signed by the person making the complaint. In your complaint, it is always helpful to provide as much detail as possible about what took place and the reason for your complaint. If you have any documents that support your complaint or help explain what happened then please include copies of the documents with your complaint letter. Finally, please be sure to fully identify the judge or lawyer and to include a full address and phone number where you can be reached.
WTH
JURY HAD JUST LEFT ...
COMMENTS :
- mary lynn muckUnited States, Little RiverJun 24, 2016
The Elvis family deserves a fair trial within all areas of the court system. The judge presiding needs to recuse himself due to numerous lack of enforcement of orders and biased relationship with the defendant Sidney Moore. - Terri BrownUnited States, RockwallJun 23, 2016
This judge imo has multiple times given deference to the defense. It's disgusting and inappropriate to SHAKE THE DEFENDANT'S HAND after handing the case to the jury!! As well, it's inappropriate to YELL at the prosecutor during her closings, again - in FRONT OF THE JURY! He should be disciplined and OFF this case. - linda ann reyonoldsCanada, OshawaJun 23, 2016
this is wrong, as is the judge shaking the defendants hand ! - Samantha IngallsUnited States, PfafftownJun 22, 2016
Give this Family Justice... This Judge is a friend of the Accused Family... that is dirty pool - BISHOP DR REVEREND JM VIZARRETAUnited States, SpringfieldMay 22, 2016
Please lets get justice bring Heather Elvis home - Virginia LewisUnited States, CharlotteMay 11, 2016
Berkeley County remains to carry out the good old boy system MCKNIGHT - Susan DeanUnited States, JacksonvilleMay 05, 2016
This family needs justice for their missing daughters. Shocked that the people accused were allowed to move out of state!!! - Amy OwensUnited States, Myrtle BeachMar 31, 2016
It's embarrassing the way officials are handling this case. Tammy killed Amber Berbigloa too. She pretty much admitted it to me on her FB that I hope cops are watching because it's scary that she gets away with it. - Kim S DeWittCanadaMar 24, 2016
This aught to be ILLEGAL!
RECUSE Yourself Justice Markley Dennis!
It's the RIGHT thing to do! - Andra F OConnorUnited States, StamfordMar 21, 2016
Please take The Honorable Judge Markley Dennis off this case and put a judge that won't be bias who reviews just the facts and follows the law. Respectfully, afoc - Andra F OConnorUnited States, StamfordMar 20, 2016
Please have him recuse himself - this is a complete conflict of interest. - Donna RitchieUnited States, Johnson CityMar 16, 2016
I am petitioning to remove Judge Rupert Markley Dennis Jr from the Case of Heather Elvis and am in favor of The Supreme Ct. of SC to appoint a new Judge in the case. Thank you. - TRICIA KLOCKEUnited States, Myrtle BeachMar 13, 2016
Of course I will sign this. Everything about this case is wrong. SC is messed up. It's SO who you know here and how much money you have... I don't even know why they have ANY laws here. They are so slack about them. Disgusting. - Michele RiddellUnited States, ConwayMar 12, 2016
This family has suffered enough! Why must they be hurt by the judicial system as well. Very scared at the direction the world is turning! - Mike hatcherUnited States, Stone MountainMar 11, 2016
Same to me there was a little bit of favoritism. That should've never went to Charleston to see this judge that has connection with their family. The whole things a bad situation - Carissa BrunoUnited States, CharlotteMar 06, 2016
Heather deserves justice, and this new judge is not providing the justice needed. - Nikki BeckUnited StatesMar 04, 2016
I have followed this story from the beginning, as I lived in NMB, SC when Heather went missing and I have been astounded at the things this judge has allowed! This family needs justice and a judge willing to find it! God bless the Elvis family and my He bring their Heather home!! - Kay EnglandUnited States, WilmingtonMar 04, 2016
Remove this judge that has not abided by the statues and laws - Wanda EisenhowerUnited States, HendersonvilleMar 04, 2016
I believe the Elvis family should have a judge preside that clearly does not have the possibility of a conflict of interest. No family should have to travel this distance for hearings. - Carol TilghmanUnited States, Myrtle BeachMar 03, 2016
I will do anything to help with Heather Elvis!!!!!
Remove this judge that has not abided by the statues and laws,
ReplyDeleteKaren M Godfrey, Charleston, SC
I think he should never have been on this trial. Why didn't the state see this at the beginning? Also to let a friend of the defense lawyer on was totally ureal.
ReplyDelete